Think AI is replacing workers? The reality is more ironic: humans labor behind the scenes to build AI meant to replace them. The gap between hype and reality reveals uncomfortable truths about innovation, investment bubbles, and the actual human cost of chasing artificial intelligence dreams.
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff learned that $1 billion in local donations doesn't buy permission to call federal troops into San Francisco—not when 25-year friendships end and fellow billionaires publish op-eds on moral laundering.
Good Morning from San Francisco, Salesforce answered an RFP you didn't know existed. The pitch: use AI to
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff learned that $1 billion in local donations doesn't buy permission to call federal troops into San Francisco—not when 25-year friendships end and fellow billionaires publish op-eds on moral laundering.
Marc Benioff spent five days learning that billion-dollar philanthropy doesn't buy permission to call federal troops into San Francisco—not when your 25-year friendship walks out and other billionaires publish op-eds dissecting your "moral laundering."
The Salesforce CEO apologized Friday for suggesting Trump deploy the National Guard to his company's hometown, retreating after venture capitalist Ron Conway resigned from the Salesforce Foundation board Thursday and Laurene Powell Jobs excoriated him in the Wall Street Journal Friday morning. The reversal came exactly five days after Benioff told the New York Times "we don't have enough cops, so if they can be cops, I'm all for it." Trump said Wednesday he'd look into sending troops; by Friday Benioff was posting heart emojis and Golden Gate Bridge icons alongside his mea culpa.
Key Takeaways
• Salesforce CEO retreated on National Guard comments after 25-year friend Ron Conway quit foundation board, fellow billionaire published scathing op-ed
• Laurene Powell Jobs called Benioff's stance "moral laundering"—arguing billion-dollar local donations don't justify advocating for federal troops in San Francisco
• Apology came as Salesforce struggles: stock down 33%, new AI product reaching under 10% of customers, company pitching ICE contracts
• First time tech billionaire's Trump embrace backfired spectacularly—elite networks enforcing political boundaries through social abandonment, not activism
This is the first time a tech billionaire's public Trump embrace backfired this spectacularly—and the enforcement mechanism matters more than the retreat.
Tech executives pivoting to Trump faced minimal social cost until now. Attending the inauguration? Fine. Praising tariff policy? Awkward but manageable. Suggesting military deployment in the city where you've donated $1 billion while you've lived primarily in Hawaii since 2021? That's where the credit runs out.
The delta: Other tech leaders shifted right without consequence. Zuckerberg, Bezos, Pichai all attended Trump's inauguration. Benioff crossed into advocating for what Illinois Governor JB Pritzker calls an "invasion" of his own city—and discovered elite networks still enforce boundaries, just through social abandonment rather than activist pressure.
From Benioff's logic: He's San Francisco's "largest employer," gave $1B+ locally, and told the Times that buys him "permission to say what I think." He'd hired private police for the last three Dreamforces because the city couldn't provide adequate security. He wants 1,000 more SFPD officers. If National Guard can fill the gap, "I'm all for it."
From former allies' read: Powell Jobs framed it as "moral laundering, where so-called benevolence masks self-interest." Conway, who'd known Benioff 25+ years, wrote "I now barely recognize the person I have so long admired" and quit the Salesforce Foundation board Thursday. More than 180 Salesforce employees and alumni signed an open letter calling out "troubling hypocrisy."
Praising Trump at Windsor Castle dinners costs nothing. Calling for troops outside the children's hospital bearing your name? That costs 25-year friendships.
The bind for local officials: Mayor Daniel Lurie can't fully alienate Salesforce—the city's largest private employer and a crucial ally for upcoming transit ballot measures—but he can't endorse federal troops when San Francisco crime sits at "multi-decade lows" per city data. He held press conferences Tuesday insisting troops were "unwarranted and unwelcome," then after Benioff's Friday apology pivoted to praising Dreamforce as "a public safety success." An event featuring Benioff and Lurie got canceled mid-week, organizers citing rain.
The apology came during a brutal stretch for Salesforce. Stock's down 33% from its 52-week high. Agentforce, the AI product meant to fend off ChatGPT threats, has reached less than 10% of the company's 150,000+ customers. The company announced a $60 billion revenue target for 2030 at Dreamforce, but investors aren't buying the AI pivot yet.
Meanwhile Salesforce is pitching ICE to help triple enforcement teams—work revealed through leaked internal documents the same week as Benioff's National Guard comments. The U.S. government is Salesforce's biggest customer, with contracts across Army, Coast Guard, and potentially ICE worth billions. The company's also seeking regulatory approval for an $8 billion Informatica acquisition.
Benioff's Trump embrace isn't ideological drift—it's margin protection. He told the Times from his private plane en route to Dreamforce: "I think he's doing a great job." Then reportedly asked his PR person: "Too spicy?"
Turns out, yes. That's the bind: business logic says cozy up to the administration. Elite network logic says there are still lines you don't cross.
Right-wing figures tried to pull Benioff further in after the initial comments. Musk backed the National Guard idea: "It's the only solution at this point." Trump aide David Sacks, who appeared onstage with Benioff at Dreamforce Tuesday, wrote: "If the Democrats don't want you, we would be happy for you to join our team. Cancel culture is over."
But Benioff fled back within 72 hours—because losing Conway and Powell Jobs apparently matters more than gaining Sacks and Musk's approval. The social cost hit before the business benefit could materialize.
This reveals how tech's political realignment actually gets policed. It's not activists on Twitter. It's Conway resigning. It's Powell Jobs writing that "generosity is an auction—and policy is the prize awarded to the highest bidder." It's canceled events. It's open letters from your own employees.
California Governor Gavin Newsom, whose daughter is Benioff's goddaughter, issued a lengthy Wednesday statement, never naming Benioff, detailing San Francisco's crime statistics and opposing any National Guard deployment. That's how you criticize a friend who writes checks: publicly rebuke the policy, privately preserve the relationship.
Three signals matter: Does Conway return to the Salesforce Foundation? Do government contract renewals proceed normally? Do other billionaires recalibrate how far right they'll publicly shift?
The Benioff episode suggests elite networks still enforce boundaries—they've just redrawn where those boundaries sit. You can praise Trump, hire K Street lobbyists, pitch ICE contracts. You apparently can't advocate for military deployment in cities where your philanthropy is supposed to demonstrate you care. Not when you're registered to vote in Hawaii and the city's actual crime data contradicts your claims.
Whether that line holds depends on what Conway does next and whether Salesforce's government business suffers. If the friendships don't recover but the contracts keep flowing, other executives will read that clearly: lose the San Francisco social scene, keep the federal revenue. If both collapse, the calculation changes.
Benioff closed his apology with "our city makes the most progress when we all work together in a spirit of partnership"—plus emojis. He was expected to return to Hawaii shortly after. Dreamforce, featuring Matthew McConaughey introducing Metallica and standup from David Spade, concluded Thursday without further incident.
Q: What's the Salesforce-ICE connection mentioned in the article?
A: Salesforce has been pitching Immigration and Customs Enforcement to use its AI agents to help triple ICE's enforcement team. The pitch was revealed through leaked internal documents the same week as Benioff's National Guard comments. The U.S. government is already Salesforce's biggest customer, with contracts across multiple agencies worth billions.
Q: Why does Ron Conway's resignation matter so much?
A: Conway is one of Silicon Valley's most connected investors—he backed Google, Airbnb, and Stripe early. He and Benioff had been close friends for 25+ years and Conway served on the Salesforce Foundation board. His resignation signals that elite tech networks still enforce social boundaries. Conway donated roughly $500,000 to Kamala Harris's 2024 campaign through various funds.
Q: How badly is Salesforce's new AI product actually performing?
A: Agentforce, Salesforce's answer to ChatGPT threats, has reached less than 10% of the company's 150,000+ customers since launch. The stock is down 33% from its 52-week high. Concerns that large language models will replace Salesforce's offerings have hammered the share price, which dropped over 25% in 2025 alone. The company projects $60 billion revenue by 2030.
Q: Was Benioff always progressive, or is this really a political shift?
A: Benioff's given to both parties for decades. He served on George W. Bush's Information Technology Advisory Committee and was close with Colin Powell, but later supported Obama, Clinton, and Harris for president. He championed Prop C—a San Francisco tax on large companies to fund homeless services—which put him at odds with other tech leaders. He told the Times he was "never a progressive" and had been Republican before becoming independent.
Q: What are San Francisco's actual crime statistics?
A: Mayor Daniel Lurie and other officials point to "multi-decade lows" in crime rates, though specific numbers weren't provided in public statements. A 2022 Chronicle analysis found San Francisco is one of California's most highly policed cities per capita according to FBI data. Governor Newsom issued a lengthy Wednesday statement detailing crime statistics showing improvement, though he didn't name specific figures publicly.
Robert Brown
Marcus Schuler
Robert Brown
Salesforce pitched AI to help ICE triple its enforcement workforce while CEO Marc Benioff embraced Trump—and a 25-year friendship fractured. Internal docs show optimization logic applied to deportation hiring. The bind: federal revenue meets reputational cost.
OpenAI's new expert council will advise on AI safety—but won't decide anything. The timing reveals the strategy: FTC inquiry in September, wrongful death lawsuit in August, council formalized last week. Advisory input without binding authority.
Jacob Silverman's Gilded Rage argues Silicon Valley's Trump embrace wasn't about wokeness or Biden hostility—it was about money. When free credit ended in 2022 and regulators pushed back, tech billionaires chose Trump over constraints.
The Netherlands seized control of Chinese-owned chipmaker Nexperia through coordinated executive rebellion and emergency law—without taking ownership. Three European managers triggered the intervention. Wingtech keeps the profits, loses the power. A new template.
Get the 5-minute Silicon Valley AI briefing, every weekday morning — free.
